The Right Way for White Balance

Facebooktwitterlinkedin

Today’s Question: I had been told long ago that the correct way to set color temperature in Lightroom Classic was to locate a neutral spot in the photo and measure it with the color temperature eye dropper. That is, when the RGB number values were about equal, the measuring spot was indeed “neutral”. Yet, I have noticed that different “neutral” spots will result in different color temperatures. Why is that, and what to do?

Tim’s Quick Answer: For most photographers using the white balance tool (the eyedropper) in Lightroom Classic is the wrong way to establish accurate color. The best approach is to adjust the Temp (color temperature) and Tint sliders based on a visual evaluation of the image and taking into account your intent for the photo.

More Detail: The white balance eyedropper in Lightroom Classic (and Camera Raw) enables you to adjust the Temp and Tint sliders based on clicking on what should be a neutral area in the image. For example, if you placed a neutral gray card in the scene you could then click on that gray card with the eyedropper and the Temp and Tint sliders would adjust so that the gray card appears perfectly gray.

The problem is that I think it is fair to say that for most photographers in most situations you wouldn’t actually want a gray card to appear perfectly neutral gray in the final image. That’s because the scene was very likely illuminated, for example, by warm light, such as in early morning or late afternoon. Neutralizing the color based on a gray card would remove the color cast that was part of the intent of capturing the photo at that time.

In addition, if you were to use the eyedropper to sample an area of the image, you would want to sample an area that should be perfectly neutral, rather than an area that just happens to be reasonably close to neutral.

One example of a scenario where you would want a neutral object to actually appear neutral is with product photography, where you generally want the colors for the product to appear accurately. In other words, you want to compensate for the color of the light source so that it appears the object was photographed under perfectly neutral white light.

If you find it helpful to use the eyedropper to neutralize color for an area of the image that was actually gray, such as overcast clouds or a neutral object that appears in the scene, you can most certainly use that as a starting point. However, it is almost always best to then refine the settings for the Temp and Tint sliders to optimize the color based on your preferences, such as to bring back the warm glow of the golden hour light the scene may have been photographed under.