Choosing a Tonal Adjustment Layer

Facebooktwitterlinkedin

Today’s Question: How would you choose between a Levels, Curves, or Light adjustment layer in Photoshop to address flatness in an image?

Tim’s Quick Answer: While all three of these adjustment layers can be used effectively to optimize overall brightness and contrast in Photoshop, I would say the Light adjustment layer is the best first choice, the Curves adjustment layer provides excellent control, and the Levels adjustment layer provides simpler basic options.

More Detail: The relatively new Light adjustment layer provides sliders for Exposure, Contrast, Highlights, Shadows, Whites, and Blacks, matching the same adjustments that are available in Camera Raw and Lightroom Classic. In general, these provide excellent control over the general tone, contrast, and detail for a photo, and so it would be my first choice. Of course, in this context there’s also a good chance that you would have achieved a good result with the same sliders in Camera Raw or Lightroom Classic prior to opening the image in Photoshop.

The Curves adjustment is the most flexible and powerful of the three adjustments that are the subject of today’s question. It is also, however, the one that can be trickiest to master. Because you can add multiple anchor points along the curve both for overall tone as well as individual color curves for the Red, Green, and Blue color channels, the Curves adjustment enables you to exercise sophisticated control over an image. That level of control isn’t something that photographers necessarily need for every image, but when you need that control the Curves adjustment is the best choice.

The Levels adjustment is the least sophisticated of the three, providing what amounts to sliders for the black point and the white point, as well as a gamma curve slider that enables you to refine overall midtone brightness and contrast. However, because the controls are so limited for Levels, it is really only suited to very basic overall adjustments for brightness and contrast, which in my view are much better addressed with the Light adjustment.